The Best Pizza On Long Island, As Chosen By Patch Readers (2024)

Skip to main content

Nearby Communities

  • Mineola, NY
  • New Hyde Park, NY
  • Malverne-Lynbrook, NY
  • East Meadow, NY
  • Rockville Centre, NY
  • Freeport, NY
  • Merrick, NY
  • Levittown, NY
  • Hicksville, NY
  • Bayside-Douglaston, NY

State Edition

  • New York

National Edition

  • Top National News
  • See All Communities

The Best Pizza On Long Island, As Chosen By Patch Readers (4)

LONG ISLAND, NY — We asked for recommendations of the best pizza places on Long Island, and boy, did you answer.

Unfortunately, there's no consensus on where the best slice is. But Patch readers had lots of recommendations.

If you're looking to try a new pizza spot, here's a list of some favorites from our readers (in no particular order). And some reasons why these places stand out.

Find out what's happening in Garden Citywith free, real-time updates from Patch.

Here are the top picks from Nassau County:

  • Green Olive Kosher Pizza in New Hyde Park
  • Monaco's in Hicksville
  • Bellagio's Pizza in Farmingdale. "The combination of dough, sauce and cheese is perfect, the employees are friendly and the pizza is also delicious when cold."
  • Via Roma in Merrick
  • Gino's in Long Beach. "We have traveled far and wide and abroad…when it comes to best U.S.A. pizza, Gino’s gets our vote."
  • Umberto's in New Hyde Park. "Their Sicilian pie is the best ever." "I grew up in New Hyde Park and currently live in Rockville Centre, and dream about the pizza there and always go back!"
  • Vincent's in Lynbrook. "From their out-of-this-world Sicilian, to their delicious Buffalo, and the traditional Neapolitan — you will never be disappointed."
  • Friendlier Pizza in Woodmere
  • Taglio Pizza in Mineola. "Neopolitan Pizza with killer crust."
  • Main Street Italian Eatery in Farmingdale
  • Phil & Sons Pizza in Syosset. "I grew up on Long Island and now live in Massachusetts. I still go there when I visit my mom and bring slices home!"
  • King Umberto's in Elmont. "Great crispy crust and they use the best ingredients."
  • Domenico's in Levittown. "Each and every pie on the menu is absolutely delicious. The sauce is amazing and there’s always a generous amount of toppings, the plain cheese pies are just as delicious and the grandma pies are the best on Long Island."
  • Naples Street Food in Oceanside. "You won't find a more authentic Italian pizza anywhere in Nassau County."
  • Ancona Pizzeria and Heroes in Valley Stream. "Been going there since I was in my mom's belly."

And if you're out east, here are readers' picks for Suffolk County:

Find out what's happening in Garden Citywith free, real-time updates from Patch.

  • Caruso's in Riverhead
  • La Bistro in Wading River. "My friends, husband and I love the Brooklyn pie. That is with the sauce on top and cheese underneath. It is the best!"
  • Jamesport Vinyard's Little Oak Pizza in Jamesport. "Amazing Neapolitan style pizza that uses local ingredients."
  • 1943 Pizza Bar in Greenport. "One of the coolest spots on Long Island." "Thin, brick oven and always delicious. Super friendly too."
  • Colosseo in Port Jefferson
  • Our Little Italy in West Islip
  • Isabella's Pizza in East Islip
  • Fattusco's Ristorante Pizzeria in Fort Salonga. "It's a hidden gem we discovered when we moved to Northport from Huntington. All their pizzas are amazing, but the MVP is in a class of its own!"
  • Dough & Co. Pizza in Huntington
  • Slice of 48 in Southold. "Slice of 48 cooks their crust to perfection. Thin not flimsy. Crispy not soggy. Their (sesame crust) is amazing."
  • Mangia's in North Babylon
  • Francesca's in Hampton Bays
  • Angela's in Islip. "Thin crust, right amount of sauce and enough cheese. Delicious."
  • Mike's Underground in Amityville. "They have true brick oven pizza with all fresh ingredients, it's even better than anything you can find on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx."
  • Paisanos Pizza in Lake Ronkonkoma. "The thin crust is crispy with delicious sauce! Never a disappointment!"
  • Renzo's in Mt Sinai. "Best best food anywhere!"
  • Fusilli Pizza in Miller Place. "The crispy crust, the home made Italian sauce, every ingredient explodes with freshness and flavor!"
  • Little Vincent's in Huntington
  • Satellite in Bayport
  • Joe's in Holbrook. "It's a step above."
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.


More from Garden City

Health & Fitness|

Boil Advisory Lifted For Several Nassau County Communities

Community Corner|

Garden City Pool Kicks Off Summer Season With Festival

Business & Tech|

Blumenfeld, Hampshire, Bespoke win LI Business Top Redevelopment Award

The Best Pizza On Long Island, As Chosen By Patch Readers (2024)


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5967

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.